Score: 8

"Another Great job..."

submission: Red And White Christmas!

date: December 28, 2007

But you're overdoing the Frame by Frame, two colors thing. I'd like to see some more stuff by you, fishhook, without other people thrown into the mix. You do really well putting these together, but it doesn't show much for your personal artistic talent.

Other than that, all of the parts were good. I didn't see anything amazing, but thrown together it definatly made something special. Great job.

Score: 9

"It's really supurb..."

submission: 1 Hour Party Time Collab!

date: November 17, 2007

That we could finish it in that amount of time. Great job at putting it together.

Score: 9

"Funny and Short is always a good combination"

submission: Raving Rabbids Commercial

date: November 17, 2007

The graphics could have been a little smoother, but if I complained about it then I would be a hypocrite. It was random enough to be funny and animated well enough for me to comment on it. Great job.

Score: 9

"Amazing game"

submission: (+) Argent Burst

date: November 12, 2007

jmtb, you've done it again. The game was so addicting that I beat it 3 times. It has that "Geometry Wars" type of nostalgia to it. The only problem, in my opinion, was that it was much too easy. Other than that, keep it up.

Score: 3

"I hate Dems."

submission: Decision 08-Democrats

date: October 27, 2007

But in all truth, it just wasn't a very good game. Actually, it wasn't a game at all. If I were you, I'd spice it up a bit.

Score: 5

"Oh man,"

submission: The Sketch Collab 07'

date: October 26, 2007

I hate to say it, but it truly wasn't that good. If it weren't a collab I don't think It would be able to pass through the portal. Next time you guys do FBF, try to make it a little smoother and make sure that it has some point- Lines REALLY get annoying after a while.

Score: 7

"Great Job, but it's not really you're style."

submission: Mad World.

date: October 20, 2007

I liked the animation, but it just wasn't happy (Which is what I've come to expect from you). Also, the song seemed to be cut a little short. Other than that, good job.

Score: 7

"I dunno,"

submission: Black And White Collab 5!

date: October 16, 2007

First of all, great job guys. Sorry I held out on this one, but it was really good. Secondly, I don't think it was the BEST. Far from it in fact. It was good, but it just didn't cut it on the "FBF" Side. There seemed to be a little too much tweening.

Again, great job, all of you.

Score: 5

"It was ooookay...."

submission: Evil Aliens

date: October 13, 2007

But I have some constructive criticism. For one thing, attention to detail- unless it's a circle or square originally, don't use the circle tool. I know from experience that the brush tool is WAY better.

Also, unless you're great with it, don't use the pencil tool often. For backgrounds, maybe, but when it comes to characters and props then the brush is the way to go.

It was okay, but next time, work a little harder on the drawing.

Score: 9

"Nice one, guys."

submission: NG Sketchbook Tour 07

date: September 30, 2007

I need to join this next year.